Rajendra Nayak Ganesh Pai The Authority for Advance Rulings (AAR) in India, in the case of E*Trade Mauritius Ltd. (taxpayer) [2010- TIOL-20-ARA-IT] recently ruled on the taxability of sale of shares of an Indian company under the India-Mauritius Tax Treaty (treaty). The taxpayer, a tax resident of Mauritius (having a tax residency certificate) held shares in an Indian company which were transferred to another Mauritius company. The taxpayer claimed that gains arising on such transfer were not taxable in India but was taxable only in Mauritius, under the treaty. However, the tax authority had earlier (before the taxpayer requested a ruling from the AAR) sought to deny the capital gains tax benefit to the taxpayer and had issued a withholding tax order directing the payer to withhold taxes on the gains. Against such order, the taxpayer filed a writ petition before the Bombay High Court. The court, without adjudicating on the technical merits of the case, had directed the release of the tax amount from the transaction in favor of the tax authority. Aggrieved by this, the taxpayer filed an application before the AAR seeking a ruling on the taxability of the sale of shares in such transaction.
April 30 2010