Jobst Wilmanns Dirk Wilcke In 2008, Germany introduced two new concepts into its transfer pricing regime, the transfer of functions and the hypothetical price comparison. Both are interlinked. The function transferred to a foreign related party is to be valued as a whole, rather than as the sum of the individual asset values. The hypothetical price comparison is the most appropriate point within the range between the lowest price at which a seller would still be willing to sell and the highest price a buyer would still be prepared to pay. Both values assume full knowledge of the circumstances on the part of everyone involved, but both are nonetheless subjective, if only because an actual buyer cannot, in the nature of things, be consulted. Not surprisingly the new concepts were met with scathing criticism.
June 30 2010