Stefan Ditsch A German investment fund loaned a sum to a US fund in return for a share in the profits. The tax office saw the interest as equivalent to a dividend and sought to tax it as such in Germany with a credit for the US tax actually borne. The Supreme Tax Court, though, has now held the income to be exempt in Germany under the general rule in the treaty that exempts income taxable in the country of source from further taxation in the country of receipt, unless the treaty specifically provides otherwise. This, in the view of the court, it does not do. The dividend article has a sub-clause allowing the country of source to tax income from profit sharing loans as dividends and the avoidance of double taxation article substitutes the credit method for the exemption method for dividends. However, the latter article does not refer to "income taxed as dividends" but only to "dividends". Profit-based interest is not a dividend in the general sense of the term and therefore not subject to the substitution. The court saw this result as unsatisfactory, but did not feel able to depart from the wording of the treaty.
September 30 2010