Rajendra Nayak Ganesh Pai The Delhi Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) in the case of Rolls Royce (2009-TIOL-103-ITAT-DEL) recently examined certain issues relating to attribution of profits to a permanent establishment (PE). Rolls Royce is a company incorporated in the UK and is engaged in the business of supplying aero engines to Indian customers. Under an agreement, its UK subsidiary, Rolls Royce India Limited (RRIL), through its offices in India, provided marketing, business development and other support services to the taxpayer on a cost-plus basis. In an earlier order of the ITAT relating to the taxpayer, it was held that RRIL was a dependent agent of the taxpayer and the taxpayer through RRIL, had a dependent agent PE in India under article 5(4) of the double taxation avoidance agreement between India and UK.
March 31 2009